GE vs. Rolls-Royce: Why Qatar Airways Made a $10B Choice for Its Massive Boeing 787 Dreamliner Order?

Qatar Airways’ recent record-breaking order for over 400 GE Aerospace engines, which includes 60 GE9X and 260 GEnx engines, demonstrates a bold dedication to securing the airline’s competitive advantage for decades and defining the future of aviation in the Middle East. This agreement, the largest widebody engine procurement in GE Aerospace’s history, will power Qatar Airways’ next-generation Boeing 777-9 and 787 fleets. The decision is a combination of strategic foresight, technical merit, and necessity.

Qatar Airways has no choice but to opt for the GE9X engine for the Boeing 777X. The GE9X is the only engine available for the 777X family, which includes the 777-9 and 777-8, as no other engine is certified or available for this aircraft type. The GE9X is not only the world’s largest and most powerful commercial aircraft engine, boasting a certified thrust of 105,000 pounds and a fan diameter of nearly 12 feet, but it also provides a 10% improvement in specific fuel consumption compared to its predecessor, the GE90-115B. Its emissions performance is a generation ahead of any competitor, and its engineering guarantees operational efficiency and reliability, thereby supporting Qatar Airways’ objective of maintaining a modern, fuel-efficient, and environmentally advanced fleet.

However, when it comes to the Dreamliner, Qatar can choose between the General Electric GEnx-1B and the Rolls-Royce Trent 1000 engines. Although Qatar Airways already operates Rolls-Royce engines on its Airbus fleet, the GEnx-1B was selected over the Trent 1000 due to several compelling factors. In comparison to the Trent 1000, the GEnx-1B has established a reputation for exceptional reliability, with fewer unplanned maintenance events and extended intervals between overhauls. In its early versions, Rolls-Royce’s engine was plagued by blade fractures, turbine degradation, and high maintenance requirements, which resulted in costly repairs and operational disruptions for airlines worldwide.

The GEnx-1B also provides superior fuel efficiency, reduced weight, and advanced materials, which directly translates to reduced operational costs throughout the engine’s lifespan. In particular, the GEnx-1B has a 2–3% lower fuel burn than the Rolls-Royce Trent 1000. This difference is due to the fact that it has a higher-pressure 10-stage high-pressure compressor (23:1 pressure ratio versus the Trent’s 8-stage, 19:1 ratio) and advanced carbon-fiber composite fan blades and fan case, which render it lighter and more efficient. Although the Trent 1000 has a slightly higher bypass ratio (10:1 vs. 9.6:1), its heavier titanium fan blades and increased cooling requirements negate this advantage, resulting in higher fuel consumption and emissions in comparison to the GEnx-1B. The GEnx-1B’s environmental benefits are even stronger because of its Twin Annular Pre-Swirl (TAPS) combustor, which meets ICAO standards and cuts nitrogen oxide emissions by 55%, making it much better than the Trent 1000. The GEnx-1B is currently powering approximately 60% of all Boeing 787s, which is a clear indication of the widespread industry’s confidence in its cost-effectiveness and performance as a result of these operational and environmental advantages. Qatar Airways accrues substantial advantages in terms of fleet commonality, streamlined maintenance, unified training, and simplified parts logistics by adopting GE engines for both the 777X and 787. These advantages are less pronounced with the Trent 1000, which is exclusively available for the 787 and not for other Boeing widebodies. GE’s comprehensive global support network, which includes a dedicated On Wing Support Center in Doha, further enhances operational predictability and reduces downtime. Conversely, Rolls-Royce’s assistance, although thorough, has not entirely alleviated the effects of previous reliability and maintenance issues associated with the Trent 1000.

The GEnx-1B’s operational efficacy and reduced weight result in lower operating costs throughout the engine’s lifespan. In a highly competitive industry, airlines are able to carry more passengers or freight for the same quantity of fuel, which is a substantial economic advantage. The GEnx-1B is equipped with sophisticated cooling technologies and advanced materials, including titanium aluminide low-pressure turbine blades, which increase the duration on the wing and decrease the frequency of unscheduled maintenance events. Conversely, the Trent 1000 has encountered numerous airworthiness directives that have grounded aircraft and disrupted airline schedules, as well as blade cracking, turbine wear, and fan blade fatigue in its early variants. These issues have resulted in more frequent maintenance checks, shorter intervals between overhauls, and a lack of reliability. The Trent 1000’s increased maintenance burden has resulted in increased operating costs and reduced fleet availability for operators, while the GEnx-1B’s extended service intervals and fewer unscheduled removals allow airlines to experience less disruption and lower maintenance costs over time.

The GEnx-1B’s 99.98% dispatch rate is further evidence of its reliability, which is a critical factor for airlines with high utilization rates and congested schedules. This rate minimizes disruptions and maximizes aircraft availability. This high dispatch reliability is in stark contrast to the Trent 1000, which, despite improvements in newer variants such as the Trent 1000 TEN, still retains the legacy of reliability concerns that have impacted airline confidence and operational planning. The past reliability problems of the Trent 1000 still affect airlines when they decide which engines to buy, while the GEnx-1B offers better predictability and benefits from GE’s ongoing updates, making it a safer and more efficient choice for airlines.

Additionally, the GE9X and GEnx engines are certified to operate on current sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) mixtures, which is consistent with Qatar Airways’ sustainability commitments and future regulatory requirements. In addition, the expanded partnership with GE Aerospace ensures long-term service and support, and it capitalizes on GE’s investment in local personnel development and training in Qatar.

In summary, Qatar Airways’ decision to double down on GE Aerospace engines is motivated by a combination of necessity (for the 777X), technical superiority, operational reliability, and strategic alignment for the 787 fleet. Despite Qatar’s existing relationship with Rolls-Royce on its Airbus fleet, the GEnx-1B’s proven track record, reduced maintenance burden, and superior fuel efficiency decisively favored it over the Rolls-Royce Trent 1000. This action enables Qatar Airways to expand its global presence while simultaneously ensuring that its fleet remains modern, efficient, and resilient.

More of the Same

Domestic PD-8 Engine Powers Superjet to Record 25-Degree Angle in Critical Test

The first Superjet 100 (SJ-100) to be powered by domestically produced PD-8 engines is a significant milestone in Russia's pursuit of aviation self-sufficiency, particularly...

PD-14 Engine’s Big Promise – But Will It Revive Russia’s Aging Fleet?

Aviation enthusiasts often advocate for the re-engining of outdated Soviet aircraft with newly developed and promising Russian engines. The PD-14 engine is recommended for...

Be-200’s Future Hangs on PD-8 Engine— What’s Next for Russia’s Amphibious Aircraft?

The appearance of new engines on the Be-200 amphibious aircraft after 2022 has been repeatedly announced. With the long-awaited domestic PD-8 engines beginning flight...

Russia’s Homegrown Superjet Takes Flight with New PD-8 Engines

A new prototype of Russia's Superjet, which is equipped with domestically produced PD-8 engines, successfully completed its maiden flight in Komsomolsk-on-Amur. This achievement is...